Rekey vs. Replace Locks: Which Is Better for Your Home? (2026 Guide)
Rekey vs replace locks: Which is better? Rekey offers significant savings vs full replacement. Complete 2026 guide for LA homeowners.

Rekey vs. Replace Locks: Which Is Better for Your Home? (2026 Guide)
Moving into a new home? Lost your keys? Upgrading security? You're facing a common dilemma: should you rekey your existing locks or replace them entirely?
This comprehensive guide breaks down the costs, benefits, and best use cases for each option β so you can make the smart choice for your home and budget.
π Quick Answer: Rekey vs. Replace
Choose Rekeying When:
β Locks are in good condition β You want to save money (significant savings) β You're moving into a new home β Keys are lost or stolen β You want one key for all locks (keyed alike)
Time: 10β15 minutes per lock
Choose Replacement When:
β Locks are damaged or worn β You want to upgrade security β Locks are outdated (10+ years old) β You want smart lock features β Locks are different brands and can't be rekeyed alike
Time: 20β45 minutes per lock
π What Does "Rekeying" Mean?
Rekeying means changing the internal pins inside your lock cylinder so that old keys no longer work, but the lock hardware itself stays the same.
How Rekeying Works:
- Locksmith removes the lock cylinder from the door
- Old pins are removed (these matched your old key)
- New pins are installed (matched to your new key)
- Lock is reassembled and tested with the new key
- Old keys no longer work β only the new key operates the lock
What Stays the Same:
- The lock body (exterior hardware)
- The knob or lever handle
- The deadbolt mechanism
- The finish and appearance
What Changes:
- Which keys operate the lock
- The internal pin configuration
- Security (if you use higher-security pins)
π§ What Does "Replacing Locks" Mean?
Replacing locks means removing the entire lock assembly and installing brand-new hardware.
What Gets Replaced:
- Entire lock cylinder
- Knob or lever handle
- Deadbolt (if applicable)
- Strike plate
- All internal mechanisms
Benefits of Replacement:
- Brand-new hardware (no wear and tear)
- Updated security features
- Modern aesthetics
- Smart lock capability
- Higher security ratings (Grade 1 vs. Grade 3)
π° Cost Comparison: Rekey vs. Replace
Rekeying Costs (Los Angeles):
Total for 5-lock house: Call for pricing (including service call)
Replacement Costs (Los Angeles):
Total for 5-lock house (mid-grade hardware): Call for pricing+
Cost Difference:
Rekeying saves you significantly compared to replacement.
Example: A 5-lock home costs:
- Rekey: Call for pricing average
- Replace: Call for pricing average (mid-grade hardware)
- Savings: Call for pricing by rekeying
π When Rekeying Is the Best Choice
Scenario 1: Moving Into a New Home
Why rekey: You don't know who has copies of the old keys (previous owners, realtors, contractors, neighbors).
Time: 45β90 minutes Benefit: Peace of mind without replacing perfectly good hardware
π‘ Pro tip: Rekey all exterior doors (front, back, side, garage) when you move in. This is the #1 security upgrade new homeowners should make.
Scenario 2: Lost Keys
Why rekey: If you lost your keys and they weren't stolen, rekeying prevents anyone who finds them from entering.
Time: 10β15 minutes per lock Benefit: Much cheaper than replacement, same security outcome
Exception: If keys were stolen along with identifying information (mail, ID, etc.), consider replacement + rekeying for maximum security.
Scenario 3: Keys Stolen (Without ID)
Why rekey: Similar to lost keys, but with higher theft risk.
Time: 10β15 minutes per lock Benefit: Quick security restoration
Additional steps:
- File a police report
- Monitor your home for suspicious activity
- Consider adding security cameras or alarm system
Scenario 4: Roommate or Tenant Moved Out
Why rekey: Former roommates or tenants may have made copies of their keys.
Time: 10β15 minutes per lock Benefit: Prevents unauthorized re-entry
Legal note: In California, landlords must rekey or change locks between tenants. Tenants can request rekeying at any time (landlord may charge reasonable fee).
Scenario 5: Want One Key for All Locks
Why rekey: If your locks are the same brand, they can be "keyed alike" β one key operates all doors.
Time: 10β15 minutes per lock Benefit: Convenience of carrying one key
Requirement: All locks must be the same brand (or compatible brands):
- Kwikset locks can be keyed alike with other Kwikset
- Schlage locks can be keyed alike with other Schlage
- Cross-brand rekeying not possible (Kwikset β Schlage)
Scenario 6: Budget Constraints
Why rekey: If you're on a tight budget, rekeying provides security at a fraction of replacement cost.
Savings: Significant Benefit: Same security outcome (old keys don't work) for less money
π When Replacement Is the Best Choice
Scenario 1: Damaged or Worn Locks
Signs your locks need replacement:
- Key is hard to insert or turn
- Lock sticks or jams frequently
- Knob or lever is loose or wobbly
- Visible rust, corrosion, or damage
- Lock doesn't latch properly
Why replace: Rekeying won't fix mechanical problems. Worn locks are security risks and can fail completely.
Benefit: Brand-new, reliable hardware with warranty
Scenario 2: Upgrading Security
Why replace: Older locks (especially 10+ years) may not meet current security standards.
Upgrade options:
- Grade 1 locks: Commercial-grade security (highest residential rating)
- High-security locks: Medeco, Mul-T-Lock (pick-resistant, drill-resistant)
- Smart locks: Keyless entry, remote access, activity logs
- Bump-proof locks: Prevents lock bumping attacks
Benefit: Significantly improved security against break-ins
Scenario 3: Outdated Locks (10+ Years Old)
Signs your locks are outdated:
- Brass or gold finish (popular in 1980sβ1990s)
- No anti-pick pins
- Basic keyway (easy to pick)
- No security rating label
- Worn finish or visible age
Why replace: Lock technology has advanced significantly. Modern locks offer:
- Pick resistance
- Drill resistance
- Bump resistance
- Better durability
- Smart features
Benefit: Modern security features and aesthetics
Scenario 4: Different Lock Brands (Can't Key Alike)
The problem: Your home has mixed brands (e.g., Kwikset front door, Schlage back door, Yale side door).
Option A β Rekey each brand separately:
- Keep existing hardware
- Have 2β3 different keys (one per brand)
- Cost: Call for pricing per lock
Option B β Replace all locks with same brand:
- Install matching locks throughout
- One key for all doors
- Cost: Call for pricing+ per lock
Recommendation: If you're tired of carrying multiple keys, replacement with matching brands is worth the investment.
Scenario 5: Want Smart Lock Features
Why replace: Smart locks require complete hardware replacement.
Popular smart locks:
- August Wi-Fi Smart Lock (Call for pricing): Retrofit design, keeps exterior hardware
- Yale Assure Lock (Call for pricing): Touchscreen keypad, Z-Wave/Zigbee
- Schlage Encode (Call for pricing): Built-in WiFi, works with Alexa/Google
- Kwikset Halo (Call for pricing): WiFi enabled, smartphone control
Features you get:
- Keyless entry (code, fingerprint, or smartphone)
- Remote lock/unlock from anywhere
- Activity logs (see who entered and when)
- Temporary access codes (for guests, cleaners, dog walkers)
- Auto-lock features
- Integration with smart home systems
Benefit: Ultimate convenience and modern security features
Scenario 6: Aesthetic Upgrade
Why replace: You're renovating or want to update your home's look.
Popular finishes:
- Matte black (modern, trending)
- Satin nickel (contemporary)
- Venetian bronze (traditional)
- Polished chrome (sleek)
- Oil-rubbed bronze (rustic)
Benefit: Improved curb appeal and home value
βοΈ Decision Matrix: Rekey or Replace?
Answer These Questions:
1. Are your locks in good working condition?
- β Yes β Lean toward rekey
- β No β Replace
2. Are your locks less than 10 years old?
- β Yes β Lean toward rekey
- β No β Consider replacement
3. Do you want to upgrade to smart locks?
- β Yes β Replace (required)
- β No β Either option works
4. Is budget a primary concern?
- β Yes β Rekey (significant savings)
- β No β Either option works
5. Are all your locks the same brand?
- β Yes β Rekey (can key alike)
- β No β Replace (if you want one key)
6. Are you moving into a new home?
- β Yes β Rekey (standard practice)
- β No β Depends on other factors
Quick Decision Guide:
| Situation | Best Choice | Why | |-----------|-------------|-----| | Moving into new home | Rekey | Cost-effective security | | Lost keys (not stolen) | Rekey | Same outcome, less cost | | Damaged/worn locks | Replace | Rekey won't fix mechanical issues | | Want smart locks | Replace | Required for smart features | | Upgrading security | Replace | Modern locks = better protection | | Budget-conscious | Rekey | significant savings | | Mixed lock brands | Replace | Get one key for all doors | | Aesthetic upgrade | Replace | New finishes, modern look |
π οΈ Can You Rekey and Replace Some Locks?
Yes! Many homeowners choose a hybrid approach:
Example Scenario:
You're moving into a home with:
- Front door: High-quality Schlage lock (2 years old)
- Back door: Worn Kwikset lock (15 years old)
- Side door: Basic builder-grade lock (unknown age)
- Garage entry: Decent condition but different brand
Hybrid solution:
- Front door: Rekey (Call for pricing) β lock is still good
- Back door: Replace (Call for pricing) β worn out, needs upgrade
- Side door: Replace (Call for pricing) β upgrade security
- Garage entry: Rekey (Call for pricing) β functional, just needs new key
Total cost: Call for pricing (vs. Call for pricing for all replacement)
Benefit: Save money while upgrading where it matters most.
π Security Considerations
Does Rekeying Improve Security?
Rekeying alone: No significant security improvement (same lock, just different keys)
Rekeying with security pins: Yes! Ask your locksmith to install:
- Spool pins: Resist picking
- Serrated pins: Resist picking
- Mushroom pins: Resist picking and bumping
Benefit: Pick-resistant security without full replacement
Does Replacement Improve Security?
Yes, significantly β if you choose higher-security locks:
Security upgrades available:
- Grade 1 locks: Commercial-grade (highest residential rating)
- High-security cylinders: Medeco, Mul-T-Lock (pick/drill resistant)
- Bump-proof locks: Prevents lock bumping attacks
- Smart locks: Activity logs, remote monitoring, temporary codes
Benefit: Substantially improved break-in resistance
π Los Angeles-Specific Considerations
Earthquake Safety
LA homeowners should consider:
- Locks that don't jam after minor seismic activity
- Deadbolts that can be opened from inside without key (safety egress)
- Regular inspection for frame alignment issues
Recommendation: Replace locks that are 15+ years old in earthquake-prone areas.
Climate Considerations
Los Angeles weather affects locks:
- Coastal areas (Santa Monica, Venice): Salt air causes corrosion
- Valley areas (Van Nuys, Encino): Heat accelerates wear
- Urban areas (Downtown, Hollywood): Pollution buildup
Recommendation: Coastal homeowners should replace locks every 7β10 years (vs. 10β15 years inland).
π° Cost-Saving Tips
1. Bundle Services
Locksmiths often discount per-lock pricing for multiple locks:
- 1β3 locks: Standard pricing
- 4β6 locks: significant savings
- 7+ locks: significant savings
Savings: Call for pricing for whole-house rekeying
2. Provide Your Own Hardware
If replacing locks:
- Purchase locks yourself (Home Depot, Lowe's, online)
- Locksmith charges labor only (Call for pricing per lock)
- Warning: Some locksmiths won't warranty customer-supplied hardware
Savings: Call for pricing per lock (retail markup avoided)
3. Schedule During Business Hours
Avoid after-hours premiums:
- Business hours (8amβ6pm): Standard pricing
- After-hours: +Call for pricing
- Weekends: +Call for pricing
Savings: Call for pricing by scheduling MondayβFriday
4. Ask About Discounts
Many locksmiths offer:
- Senior discount: significant savings (65+)
- Military discount: significant savings
- First responder discount: significant savings
Savings: Call for pricing on typical service
π Frequently Asked Questions
How long does rekeying take?
- Per lock: 10β15 minutes
- Whole house (5 locks): 45β90 minutes
- Car locks: 15β30 minutes (more complex)
Can all locks be rekeyed?
Most residential locks can be rekeyed, including:
- Kwikset
- Schlage
- Weiser
- Yale
- Defiant
Exceptions:
- Very old locks (pre-1970s)
- Specialty high-security locks (require manufacturer)
- Damaged locks (must be replaced)
- Mixed brands (can rekey, but won't key alike)
Do I need to rekey if I lost my keys?
Yes, if:
- Keys were stolen
- Keys had your address on them
- You're moving into a new home
- A roommate/tenant moved out
No, if:
- You have a spare key
- Keys were lost in a secure location (e.g., inside your home)
- You're certain keys can't be used to access your home
Is it worth rekeying old locks?
Depends on condition:
- Good condition: Yes, rekeying is cost-effective
- Worn or damaged: No, replace instead
- 10+ years old: Consider replacement for security upgrade
Can I rekey my locks myself?
Technically yes, but not recommended:
- Requires special tools (rekeying kit, pinning tray, key gauge)
- Easy to damage lock if done incorrectly
- Time-consuming for beginners (1β2 hours per lock)
- Professional locksmith: 10β15 minutes per lock
Cost comparison:
- DIY rekeying kit: Call for pricing (one-time purchase)
- Professional rekeying: Call for pricing per lock
- Break-even: 1β2 locks (after that, kit pays for itself)
Verdict: Worth it if you're handy and plan to rekey multiple properties. Otherwise, hire a pro.
What happens to my old keys after rekeying?
Old keys no longer work on rekeyed locks. You can:
- Destroy them (recommended for security)
- Keep as backups (won't work, but no harm)
- Give to locksmith (they'll recycle/dispose)
Should I rekey before or after painting?
After painting:
- Remove locks before painting doors
- Paint door, let dry completely
- Reinstall or rekey locks afterward
Why: Paint can gum up lock mechanisms and void warranties.
π When to Call EasyWay Locksmith
Call (818) 616-(818) 873-5131 for: β Professional rekeying service (Call for pricing per lock) β Lock replacement and installation β Security assessments β Smart lock installation β Whole-house rekeying (discounted pricing) β Emergency lockout service
Service area: All of Los Angeles County
Why choose EasyWay:
- π Licensed & Insured: LCO #7615
- β±οΈ 20-Minute Arrival: Technicians across LA
- π° Transparent Pricing: No hidden fees
- π 24/7/365 Service: Available nights, weekends, holidays
- π³ All Payment Methods: Credit cards, cash, digital payments
- β 5-Star Rated: 500+ verified customer reviews
π Final Thoughts: Make the Smart Choice
Rekeying is the best choice when:
- Locks are in good condition
- You want to save money (significant savings)
- You're moving into a new home
- You lost keys (not stolen)
Replacement is the best choice when:
- Locks are damaged or worn
- You want to upgrade security
- You want smart lock features
- Locks are 10+ years old
Not sure? Call EasyWay Locksmith for a free on-site assessment. Our licensed technicians will inspect your locks and recommend the best solution for your security needs and budget.
π Need locksmith service in Los Angeles?
Call EasyWay Locksmith: (818) 616-(818) 873-5131
Free estimates β’ Licensed LCO #7615 β’ 20-minute arrival
Related Articles:
Need a locksmith right now?
Licensed technicians at your door in under 20 minutes β 24/7 across Los Angeles.
